However, more recently, experts have been questioning the cholesterol hypothesis.
This article explains the theory, its implications, and factors besides cholesterol that researchers are considering.
What Is the Cholesterol Hypothesis?
Stocktrek Images/Getty Images
Specifically, they recommend reducing saturated fat intake and replacing it with unsaturated fat, especially polyunsaturated fat.
For decades, experts urged people to alter their diets to reduce cholesterol levels.
In addition, pharmaceutical companies spent billions of dollars developing drugs for lowering cholesterol.
The cholesterol hypothesis became ingrained among healthcare providers, the medical community, and the population at large.
But that has not been shown.
Non-Statin Therapies
Some studies found substantially lowered LDL cholesterol levels with non-statin therapies.
However, they did not show improved cardiovascular outcomes.
However, reducing them with other interventions does not.
This result suggests that the benefits of cholesterol-lowering seen with statin therapy are specific to the statins themselves.
For this reason, the cholesterol hypothesis, at least in its classic form, is now being questioned.
Statins represent a special case when it comes to cholesterol-lowering therapy.
Statins havemany effectson the cardiovascular system.
Drugs that lower cholesterol without having these other plaque-stabilizing characteristics seem not to result in this kind of benefit.
Therefore, it is reasonable to postulate that statins do not improve cardiovascular risk only by reducing cholesterol levels.
Instead, they might be doing so through these other effects.
Instead, the guidelines focused on decidingwhich people should treat their condition with statins.
In fact, for most people, these guidelines generally recommend against using non-statin drugs to lower cholesterol.
These guidelines created tremendous controversy within the cardiology community.
Experts are questioning the cholesterol hypothesis.
Thats because studies have found that non-statin therapies alone have not improved outcomes.
It has been considered that statins other effects on the body may play a role in their clinical benefit.
Some questions experts are considering include:
Experts have different ideas for how to move forward.
Trials looking at diet to reduce cholesterol have shown an improvement in clinical outcomes.
Revising the Cholesterol Hypothesis
Other expertslikely the majoritystill agree with the idea that cholesterol levels are important.
Given this line of evidence, it seems premature to assert that cholesterol levels do not matter.
Any hypothesis is a working model.
As you learn more, you change the model.
By this reasoning, it makes sense for the cholesterol hypothesis to be revised.
Its also the key in and behavior of thelipoprotein particlesthat carry the cholesterol.
Endothelium
The endothelium is the inner cell lining of the bodys arteries.
Scientists are rapidly learning more about the various lipoprotein particles and what influences how they behave.
New ways of changing the behaviors of these lipoproteins may help reduce cardiovascular disease.
But, recently, more experts are suggesting that the hypothesis is too simplistic.
Thats because the range of results from cholesterol-lowering trials is inconsistent.
Namely, some studies have found that lowering cholesterol alone does not consistently improve outcomes.
Some studies indicate that statins additional benefits may play a role in why they work.
Experts are in an uncomfortable place where the hypothesis and associated guidelines may need modification.
There is not a replacement yet.
2017;136(3):e1-e23.
2019;139(25):e1082-e1143.
2018;11(10):959-970. doi:10.1080/17512433.2018.1519391
DuBroff R.A reappraisal of the lipid hypothesis.Am J Med.
2015;161(1):161-172. doi:10.1016/j.cell.2015.01.036
